How to Cook Fish Perfectly Everytime (Plus 2 Recipes)

Tim Harrison

Athlete's Table

Food, Kettlebells

"Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication."

- Leonardo Da Vinci


As a Hardstyle kettlebell coach this is pretty much my training mantra, but it also applies to cooking, especially fish. There are only two ways I cook fish at home - frying and poaching - and I use the former far more often than the latter.



Fish is a much more delicate protein than meat, so it requires a delicate hand. Overcooked fish isn’t inedible, but a properly handled piece is much better.



Frying: Basic Method

Frying, often tautologically referred to as pan-frying (can you fry in anything else?), is my go-to method. Like I said about that recipe for brassicas and greens, if you are unsure what to do, do this and it will be great.


"You are probably already aware of the visual change as fish cooks. It loses the translucence and takes on a more opaque quality. Watching for this change is really all you need to know."

The main key to frying a piece of fish well is observation. You are probably already aware of the visual change as fish cooks. It loses the translucence and takes on a more opaque quality. Watching for this change is really all you need to know. Aside from that, here’s the basic method:


  1. Put a pan on a high heat, with a little oil. As with meat, don’t cook it straight from the fridge. Season both sides with salt only (remember pepper will burn).
  2. Put the fish into the pan, skin side down. If it curls then rest a small ramekin or saucer on top to tease it down. Don’t prod it with a spatula as this will squeeze out some of the yummies and could cause the skin to detach, and don’t slash the skin.
  3. When the fish appears opaque to about halfway through, flip it over and cook the other side for one minute.
  4. Remove and rest before serving. Then a quick sauce can be made in the pan with a squeeze of lemon or a splash of wine and a knob of butter.


Why do I cook it mostly skin side down? First, because crispy skin is tasty and limp skin is gross. If I have paid for a fillet of fish, I’m sure going to eat all of it. The skin also acts as a barrier to protect the delicate flesh from the harsh heat of the pan and stops some of the lovely oils from seeping away, which are super good for us and tasty.



Poaching: Basic Method

This is a less used method in my house, but it's still great. Poaching is better suited to larger fish or thicker portions of something like salmon, turbot, or large cod. It is important not to think of poaching as boiling. The temperature has to be a lot lower than that, at a gentle heat. As the fish cooks, the agitation of boiling will break up the flesh, leaving it scraggily.


So what we do instead of boiling is immerse the fish into a hot liquid medium, most often lightly flavored, and cook gently for about ten minutes. Notice I said liquid, because this can be done using multiple mediums:


  • Milk: Often used for smoked fish. The milk can then be used to make something like a chowder.
  • Water: Flavored with a few herbs, some vegetables, and a little vinegar. This light stock is called a court bouillon.
  • Oil: This would be referred to as confit. In all cases the temperature is kept relatively low. +50°C (+122°F) is Heston Blumenthal’s recommendation, but that may be a tad under for a lot of people, and maintaining that exact temperature is nearly impossible in a domestic setting. So instead, you can use a more old-fashioned but good technique of cooking in residual heat, as I will explain in the poached fish recipe that follows.


Continue for Two Fish Dinner Recipes


Breaking Muscle Newsletter

Get updates and special offers delivered directly to your inbox.