• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Breaking Muscle

Breaking Muscle

Breaking Muscle

  • Fitness
  • Workouts
    • Best Shoulder Workouts
    • Best Chest Workouts
    • Best Leg Workouts
    • Best Leg Exercises
    • Best Biceps Exercises
    • Best Kettlebell Exercises
    • Best Back Workouts
    • Best HIIT Workouts
    • Best Triceps Exercises
    • Best Arm Workouts
  • Reviews
    • Supplements
      • Best Pre-Workouts
      • Best Whey Protein
    • Equipment
      • Best Home Gym Machines
    • Certifications
      • ISSA Review
  • News
  • Exercise Guides
    • Legs
      • Back Squat
      • Bulgarian Split Squat
      • Goblet Squat
      • Zercher Squat
      • Standing Calf Raise
      • Hack Squat
    • Chest
      • Bench Press
      • Dumbbell Bench Press
      • Close-Grip Bench Press
      • Incline Bench Press
    • Shoulders
      • Overhead Dumbbell Press
      • Lateral Raise
    • Arms
      • Chin-Up
      • Weighted Pull-Up
      • Triceps Pushdown
    • Back
      • Deadlift
      • Trap Bar Deadlift
      • Lat Pulldown
      • Inverted Row
      • Bent-Over Barbell Row
      • Single-Arm Dumbbell Row
      • Pendlay Row
Fitness

Does Arm Action Render Heart Rate Monitors Ineffective?

Have you ever wondered if moving your arms too much might throw off your heart rate monitor? A new study asked that question and got an unexpected response.

Doug Dupont

Written by Doug Dupont Last updated on January 31, 2014

I’ve always wondered how accurate heart rate monitors could possibly be at measuring calorie burn. I even wonder sometimes how accurate they are at measuring heart rate, but in that regard they tend to be pretty reliable. A study this month in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research compared calorie burn as estimated by a heart rate monitor to standard lab test measurements.

Heart rate monitors determine calorie burn by performing a calculation based on heart rate. This measurement is actually pretty accurate, for the most part. Up to a point, there is a close linear relationship between heart rate and energy expenditure. As heart rate climbs, energy expenditure also increases by a steady amount. This is true until hyperventilation takes place to remove acid buildup in the cells and blood.

Dr. Lloyd, the researcher in charge of this study, was curious about how arm action affects the accuracy of heart rate monitor measurements. A lot of arm involvement yields a higher heart rate per calorie burned, but heart rate monitors are calibrated for leg exercise with minimal arm involvement. Heart rate also increases with upper body work because of increased parasympathetic output. This effect increases even more if the arms are overhead, probably because the heart needs to work harder to pump blood against gravity than it does down to the legs.

In this study, Dr. Lloyd used a simple design. She compared a step routine using the arms and legs to the same routine using just the legs. She measured calorie expenditure using both a Polar F6 heart rate monitor and indirect calorimetry, which is the standard lab test for measuring calorie burn through oxygen consumption.

The results were a little funky. There was an increase in heart rate relative to energy expenditure when using the arms, which we knew would happen. Although the heart rate monitor did report increased calorie burn using the arms a little bit more than it should have, the increase wasn’t statistically significant. The weird part is that the monitor overestimated the calorie burn on both kinds of step routine, with and without the arms. It did so by nearly two calories per minute, which is a pretty big swing and a miss. So, while the heart rate monitor was indeed off in its prediction of calories, it wasn’t inaccurate in the way the researchers expected.

It’s unfortunate that people might not be getting the workout they think they are with the Polar F6, but to be honest, I don’t think it’s all that bad that the heart rate monitor overestimated the calorie burn. As long it’s the only monitor you use, you will get consistent readings with it. That said, it’s good to know you’ll need to push a little bit harder with a Polar F6 to get the exercise level you’re looking for. Just keep that in mind when using it.

Although the accuracy of heart rate monitors may get thrown off a small amount by a lot of arm work, if you’re still doing leg-intensive cardio, it should be accurate enough to get the job done. That is, as long as your heart rate monitor is accurate to begin with.

References:

1. Lisa Lloyd, “Is the Polar F6 Heart Rate Monitor Less Accurate During Aerobic Bench Stepping Because of Arm Movements?” Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, DOI: 10.1519/JSC.0000000000000382

Photo courtesy of Shutterstock.

Doug Dupont

About Doug Dupont

Having grown up at the foot of a forest covered mountain in rural Vermont, Doug was active from a very young age. Hiking, running, and climbing were a part of everyday life in the Green Mountains. This culture of exercise led to dabbling in martial arts as a teen, and also getting work in a local powerlifting focused gym. Doug continued to pursue knowledge and training in exercise, becoming a certified personal trainer while still a teenager. Once in college he began his hand at the business side of fitness, taking a management position at a large local gym. During that time he became a founding member of the UVM Brazilian Jiu Jitsu club, and was the first among their competition team. After only a few months he was assisting in coaching, and ran conditioning program for the club.

Out of college Doug set up his own training center. He grew his list of clientele including several professional MMA athletes, eventually going so far as to corner a world title fight. He has continued ­­­to develop his business into today.

View All Articles

Recommended Articles

313047272911562813906957133648n
Getting the Most Out of Assistive Gear: A Motor Patterning Perspective
Method Man Incline Dumbbell Presses December 2022
Check Out Rapper Method Man Cruising Through 120-Pound Incline Dumbbell Presses for 10 Reps
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson Leg Workout
Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson Crushes 5 “Monster Sets” of a Leg Workout
Michael B. Jordan poster for Creed III
Michael B. Jordan and Jonathan Majors Look Like Shredded Boxing Stars in “Creed III”

Primary Sidebar

Latest Articles

Jamal Browner Logs a Monster 426.4-Kilogram (940-Pound) Conventional Stance Raw Deadlift

Sonita Muluh (+84KG) Scores Squat One Kilogram (2.2 Pounds) Above Raw World Record in Training

Olympia Legend Dorian Yates Describes His Favorite Back Exercise

Amanda Lawrence (84KG) Squats 11.5 Kilograms (25.3 Pounds) More Than IPF World Record In Training

Latest Reviews

ISSA Personal Trainer Certification Review

ISSA Personal Trainer Certification Review

Best Whey Proteins for Packing on Muscle, Shredding Down, Meal Replacement, and More

Best Pre-Workouts for Building Muscle, Running, Taste, and More

Best Home Gym Machines

Best Home Gym Machines

woman lifting barbell

Be the smartest person in your gym

The Breaking Muscle newsletter is everything you need to know about strength in a 3 minute read.

I WANT IN!

Breaking Muscle is the fitness world’s preeminent destination for timely, high-quality information on exercise, fitness, health, and nutrition. Our audience encompasses the entire spectrum of the fitness community: consumers, aficionados, fitness professionals, and business owners. We seek to inform, educate and advocate for this community.

  • Reviews
  • Healthy Eating
  • Workouts
  • Fitness
  • News

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS Feed

© 2023 · Breaking Muscle · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy · Affiliate Disclaimer · Accessibility · About