The Myth of More Is Better
Look around, and you will find yourself surrounded by people telling you “More Is Better.” This line of thought is also prevalent in the minds of athletes as they approach training. Unfortunately, it has led to an epidemic of Tommy John (UCL surgery) in baseball and a culture that thinks Insanity and CrossFit’s get-them-tired approach to training is the point of every workout.
In the rush to do more, we miss the true point and don’t get the results we desire. We get in a hurry or miss the essentials, and nothing sticks. We train too many competing goals and end up tired, with nothing to show for our work. It's time we examine and disprove the different fallacies related to the myth of “More Is Better.”
Fallacy #1: Do More in Less Time
I work with every sports team at a high school with limited space and facilities. By necessity, I have to get more done in less time. However, placing this emphasis on doing can cause a lot more harm than good. Many coaches and amateur lifters approach their allotted time as a test to see how many exercises can be finished in a certain period of time.
By rushing the pace, you often miss out on quality reps. One good rep far outweighs five bad ones, but we often miss this. What must be understood is that not all work contributes to getting better. Running a mile doesn’t make your 40-yard dash faster—if anything, it might make you slower. You must train for the specific goals you want to attain.
This is referred to as SAID (specific adaptations to imposed demands). A volleyball athlete needs power and strength, not a good mile time. In planning a workout for a power athlete, it’s important to lay a solid foundation and then progress to low reps and high weights, or high-rep speed movements on the strength and power end of the spectrum. Training for these goals requires complete rest between sets, anywhere from 2-5 minutes. There is no getting around it. This is how you get stronger and more powerful.
If you have limited time, it is wise to use time between sets for maintenance band drills, terminal knee extensions, or dynamic mobility drills, which won’t fatigue the lift of focus. But athletes only hurt themselves when they emphasize getting 4 sets of heavy squats done in 8 minutes. This approach does not allow ATP and CP to be replenished in the body. Form will degrade, and by default the lift shifts from the strength power end of the spectrum to the hypertrophy end. The intent is good, but the outcome misses its goal by a mile.
Maximum work in minimum time has its place, but only if it's in line with your goals.
Fallacy #2: Move More Weight
It is a common assumption that athletes aren’t working hard unless they are hitting failure often. Many coaches believe their entire job in facilitating a lift is to ensure that each athlete hits failure on every set. I’ve seen programs have everyone at a rack lift off of the strongest athlete’s max so that time isn’t wasted switching weights (because remember, you’ve got to get more done in less time).
Similarly, these programs will have another lift that is not correlated to a max. For example, the workout may be “3 sets of pull ups to failure – must hit at least 8.” What do you think the form will look like? Is the target muscle group and movement pattern being trained as the athletes flail around kicking their legs or having their partner push them up by their knees?
Let me be clear: form is primary in every lift.
Take the time to teach athletes adherence to perfect form, and they will become stronger, more disciplined, and more resilient to injuries than you may have thought possible. As Greg McKeown, author of the book Essentialism says, “With the right routine in place, each effort yields exponentially greater results.”
No athlete can maintain a long-term program that constantly forces him or her to hit absolute failure. And it would not be a successful program even if he or she could, because it would fry the nervous system. Renowned trainer of the pros, Joe DeFranco, goes so far as to say that he will train an athlete for years without letting them hit failure on any lift. He actually programs weights at a max that is 5-10 percent less than what they performed in an adrenaline-filled max-out, because that adrenaline is not there in a day to day program.
You could take this argument too far and miss your opportunity to train heavy and build a culture of toughness. This would also be a mistake. It is a sweet spot that must be found and takes an intelligent, mature coaching staff. There will still be grind-it-out, tough training sessions. However, they should never be at the expense of form or an intelligent plan.
Fallacy #3: Do More Overall
The last of the fatal flaws in the myth of “more is better” is the completely understandable idea that doing more, overall, is better. For example, if I do a workout in the morning and the afternoon, I will get better twice as fast.
In our competitive world, it stands to reason that if there is a gap between where I am and where that person is, I need to put more hours in to catch up. The problem is that if a new lifter decides to lift seven days a week in his quest to get stronger, generally his body will be overtaxed and not build muscle as fast as someone lifting four days per week.
The body follows the principle of general adaptation syndrome (G.A.S.). There are three steps:
- The body is alarmed by the workout and becomes flooded with hormones to help overcome the challenge.
- Next the body enters the resistance phase and, if proper recovery is implemented, will grow better adapted to the specific stress that was incurred (SAID Principle).
- If the body is not allowed to recover and stress persists, the body enters the exhaustion phase and breaks down.
That last phase is typified by the current epidemic of Tommy John among young pitchers. Nowadays, every parent seems to feel it is their job to be their young pitcher’s advertising company. They ignore the coach’s advice and instead, they pitch their son year-round, never even approaching the recommended four months off. His summer league pitch counts get dangerously high. In fall, he plays football during the week and then pitches on weekends. Finally, after not once allowing for rest periods or maintenance programs for his arm, the parents are shocked to hear he has a tear in his UCL.
If this is what you look like five nights a week, you probably aren't progressing like you could.
Where More Actually Is Better
So if you do have a gap in performance that you want to bridge and you are willing to work tenaciously towards your goal, how do you accomplish this goal?
- First, consult a qualified trainer with a sports performance certification. Have him or her make a clear plan that progresses intelligently and takes your specific needs and restrictions into account. The plan should address power and strength, but also speed, agility, reaction, balance, injury reduction, and mobility. Mobility may be the one instance where more is better. It helps speed and recovery and should be worked on habitually a few times a day for the best results.
- Next, make sure that you are eating correctly. More fruits and vegetables are almost always a good thing. Many athletes are unaware that they require many more quality calories to reach their goals.
- Get the best recovery you can. Take time to foam roll, find hobbies that help remove stress, and sleep 8-10 hours each night. Remember that most of the strength and positive body adaptations take place during recovery, especially during sleep.
Do these things and you are likely to avoid injury or burn-out. You will build healthy habits that will benefit you for a lifetime and be far more successful in chasing your athletic goals.
Work Out Smarter
While I commend coaches who emphasize work ethic, planning and remaining true to the fundamentals are essential. We live in a reactive society, driven to do everything, all the time. Most athletes would be far better served by a simple plan with a disciplined focus on tempo, rest intervals, and form. Workouts don’t need to be complicated, and doing more will not get you more.
A far better approach is to do less, but do it better. Be consistent, focus on the essentials, and find ways to bring an enthusiasm to your work. This is the secret behind making amazing improvements.
More Essential Training Philosophies:
- The Real Reason Your Hard Work Isn't Paying Off
- Safety: The Most Important Part of Choosing a Fitness Program
- Is Perfectionism Holding Your Training Back?
- New on Breaking Muscle Today
Photos courtesy of Jorge Huerta Photography.
Topic: Advice for Athletes
Shane Trotter is the Strength and Conditioning Coordinator at Mansfield High School. He holds the CSCS, USAW-1, and CFT certifications. He is a fitness enthusiast who has always found passion in working out, training athletes, and programming for different goals and priorities. Through training, Shane Trotter has found an amazing vehicle to impact students. He believes strongly in living an active, healthy lifestyle and helping others take control of their lives with positive habits and... Read More