• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Breaking Muscle

Breaking Muscle

Breaking Muscle

  • Fitness
  • Workouts
    • Best Shoulder Workouts
    • Best Chest Workouts
    • Best Leg Workouts
    • Best Leg Exercises
    • Best Biceps Exercises
    • Best Kettlebell Exercises
    • Best Back Workouts
    • Best HIIT Workouts
    • Best Triceps Exercises
    • Best Arm Workouts
  • Reviews
    • Supplements
      • Best Pre-Workout
      • Best Bodybuilding Supplements
      • Best Supplements for Weight Loss
      • Best Creatine
      • Best BCAAs
      • Best Multivitamin for Men
      • Best Collagen Supplement
      • Best Probiotic
      • Best Non-Stim Pre-Workout
      • Best Magnesium Supplements
      • Athletic Greens AG1 Review
    • Protein
      • Best Protein Powder
      • Best Whey Protein
      • Best Protein Powders for Muscle Gain
      • Best Mass Gainer
      • Best Protein Shakes
      • Best Organic Protein Powder
      • Best Pea Protein Powder
      • Best Protein Bars
    • Strength Equipment
      • Best Home Gym Equipment
      • Best Squat Racks
      • Best Barbells
      • Best Weightlifting Belts
      • Best Weight Plates
      • Best Weight Benches
      • Best Dumbbells
      • Best Adjustable Dumbbells
      • Best Kettlebells
      • Best Home Gym Machines
      • Best Resistance Bands
      • Best Cable Machines
      • Best Trap Bars
      • The Best Pull-Up Bar
    • Cardio Equipment
      • Best Cardio Machines
      • Best Rowing Machines
      • Best Treadmills
      • Best Weighted Vests
  • News
  • Exercise Guides
    • Legs
      • Back Squat
      • Bulgarian Split Squat
      • Goblet Squat
      • Zercher Squat
      • Standing Calf Raise
      • Hack Squat
    • Chest
      • Bench Press
      • Dumbbell Bench Press
      • Close-Grip Bench Press
      • Incline Bench Press
    • Shoulders
      • Overhead Dumbbell Press
      • Lateral Raise
    • Arms
      • Chin-Up
      • Weighted Pull-Up
      • Triceps Pushdown
    • Back
      • Deadlift
      • Trap Bar Deadlift
      • Lat Pulldown
      • Inverted Row
      • Bent-Over Barbell Row
      • Single-Arm Dumbbell Row
      • Pendlay Row
Healthy Eating

Is a Ketogenic Diet Really More Effective for Fat Loss?

The effectiveness of the ketogenic diet lies in how satiating fat is.

Sam MacIntosh

Written by Sam MacIntosh Last updated on July 13, 2016

The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition published a study last week to investigate claims that a ketogenic diet can facilitate greater fat loss than diets relatively higher in carbohydrate.

The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition published a study last week to investigate claims that a ketogenic diet can facilitate greater fat loss than diets relatively higher in carbohydrate.

Commonly known as “keto”, a ketogenic diet is a diet typically characterized by a 4:1 ratio of dietary fat to protein and carbohydrate and was originally used in the treatment of childhood epilepsy. It has been theorized that keto diets facilitate greater fat loss in humans as an absence of dietary carbohydrate forces the body to oxidize fat as its primary energy source.

Taubes and colleagues set out to test this theory. Their study was conducted over eight weeks in a research facility known as a metabolic ward. Seventeen overweight or obese volunteers participated, with no opportunity to eat foods outside of the diets of the study.

For the first four weeks, the subjects were fed a high-carbohydrate, high-sugar diet. Fifty percent of their total calories came from carbohydrate (338g per day), and 25% of their total calories came from sugar. The HCD diet totaled 2,739 calories per day.

For the second four weeks, they were fed a very-low-carbohydrate, low-sugar ketogenic diet. Five percent of their total calories came from carbohydrate (36g per day), and 2% of their total calories came from sugar. 15% percent of the calories came from protein. The keto diet totaled 2,738 calories per day. Note that the caloric intakes were kept close to identical, meaning fat loss could only be attributed to the source of the food rather than its caloric content.

The volunteers spent two days a week inside metabolic chambers, where their calorie expenditure was measured. Once every two weeks, their body composition was measured via a DEXA scan. The researchers also used doubly labeled water to measure the volunteers’ average calorie expenditure during the final two weeks of each diet.

In a fantastic online review of the study, Dr. Stephan Guyenet, a nutritional research expert, notes the study’s thoroughness and that the results, at face value, support the researchers’ initial hypothesis that a ketogenic diet promoted greater fat loss. Compared with the higher carbohydrate diet, the keto diet coincided with increased energy expenditure, meaning the subjects appeared to burn more calories when their carbohydrate levels were cut, thought they were consuming the same amount of calories as they were on the high carbohydrate diet.

But let’s look a little deeper at that. Though the subjects’ energy expenditure increased in the first two weeks of ketogenic diet, this increase eventually plateaued in the final two weeks and fell back down to the study’s baseline. What’s more, though participants lost weight rapidly in the first few days of going keto as a result of decreased water retention, body fat loss eventually also slowed. Further testing also returned that the participants on the keto diet even started to break down lean tissue for energy – not body fat.

Additionally, as also noted by Guyenet, fat mass decreased at a slower rate on the ketogenic diet than on the higher carbohydrate diet. On the ketogenic diet, the volunteers lost the same amount of body fat in one month that they lost in two weeks on the high carbohydrate diet. Guyenet comments:

“If you believe the hypothesis that sugar summons Beelzebub to plump up your fat tissue regardless of your calorie intake, the comparison should have been extremely favorable to the ketogenic diet. Yet the effect on fat mass was the opposite of what this hypothesis predicts.”

I’m biased, as I don’t believe that a ketogenic diet is an effective and uncomplicated way to lose weight in the long term. So it’s worth finishing with the point that for many trusted experts, including Guyenet, the effectiveness of the ketogenic diet lies in how satiating fat is. Fat makes us feel fuller, which commonly leads to a cumulatively lower net calorie intake and therefore, weight loss. This study removed the participants’ opportunity to eat according to their subjective hunger levels and thus the only feather in keto’s cap.

As one user on Guyenet’s blog notes, what would be interesting is a look at any data that tracked subjective hunger levels in this study, or a new study with a method that allowed for and controlled a more intuitive consumption of food. But this particular study lends little to no credence to keto.

Sam MacIntosh

About Sam MacIntosh

Sam MacIntosh is a writer, editor, and a British Weightlifting and Precision Nutrition certified coach.

Sam played football from her pre-teens through to university, briefly switching to rugby when she was 25. It was then that she was introduced to strength training and weightlifting by a teammate and began training in CrossFit in late 2013. Shortly after, Chet Morjaria of Strength Education took her on as a powerlifting athlete and coached her to first in her weight class at the 2014 Welsh Powerlifting Open. She now trains in Olympic weightlifting and is the head barbell coach at CrossFit Gain in Norwich, England.

Sam is passionate about empowering athletes to think independently and neutralising nutritional propaganda. She's a recovering perfectionist, and enjoys coffee, books, and cinnamon donuts. You can connect with her on Twitter and Instagram.

View All Articles

Recommended Articles

chinupsinthewoods
Are Plant-Based Proteins Friendly for Keto and Paleo Diets?
ketogenic diet
Does the Ketogenic Diet Work for Women?
ketogenic, carbs, nutrition, nutrients, hunger, ketones, mental health
Why a Ketogenic Approach to Nutrition Is Ideal for Your Health
low carb, low carb diet, ketogenic, ketogenic diet, paleo, zone, atkins
Ketogenic Diets Do Not Compromise Performance

Primary Sidebar

Latest Articles

Samson Dauda Trains Chest and Calves with Classic Physique Olympia Competitor Michael Daboul 

Malcolm Cooper Wins 2023 WNBF Pro Universe, Earns Mr. Universe Title

Best Protein Bars for Weight Loss, Muscle Gain, and More (2023)

How to Become a Personal Trainer in 2023

Latest Reviews

Best Magnesium Supplements of 2023 for Better Sleep, Leg Cramps, and More

Best Budget Barbells of 2023 for CrossFit, Powerlifting, and More

Best Cable Machines for Home Gyms of 2023 (Wall-Mounted, Compact, Budget-Friendly)

The Best Pull-Up Bar of 2023, According to a Strength and Conditioning Coach

woman lifting barbell

Be the smartest person in your gym

The Breaking Muscle newsletter is everything you need to know about strength in a 3 minute read.

I WANT IN!

Breaking Muscle is the fitness world’s preeminent destination for timely, high-quality information on exercise, fitness, health, and nutrition. Our audience encompasses the entire spectrum of the fitness community: consumers, aficionados, fitness professionals, and business owners. We seek to inform, educate and advocate for this community.

  • Reviews
  • Healthy Eating
  • Workouts
  • Fitness
  • News

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS Feed

© 2023 · Breaking Muscle · Terms of Use · Privacy Policy · Affiliate Disclaimer · Accessibility · About